5891 New Jersey St Indianapolis, IN 46220 / 2534

Residence for Single Family

(UPDATED: 08/14/2025)
  • 5 Beds
  • 3 Baths
  • 3.789 square feet
Property Report

Information about property on 5891 New Jersey St, Indianapolis IN, 46220-2534. Find out owner contacts, building history, price, neighborhood at Homemetry Address Directory.

Property Details

At 5891 New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN stands a large two-story single-family possession.

Facts

  • Built in 1927
  • Lot size 6,969 sqft
  • Floor size 3,789 sqft
  • Rooms 13
  • Bedrooms 5
  • Bathrooms 3
  • Stories 2
  • Last remodel year 1952
  • Heating & Cooling
  • Heat type Other
  • Cooling Central
  • Interior Home Features
  • Flooring Carpet, Hardwood, Tile
  • Exterior Home Features
  • Exterior material Brick
  • Parking & Garage
  • Parking Garage - Detached, 2 spaces, 400 sqft

Misc

  • Units 1

Listing info

  • Last sold Jun 2013 for $425,000

Features

  • Attic
  • Fireplace
  • Skylight
  • Wet Bar
  • Dishwasher
  • Dryer
  • Microwave
  • Laundry: In Unit

Householders and Tenants for 5891 New Jersey St, Indianapolis IN

Possible residents contact details

Person Name Phone Number Additional Info
Adam J Fisch
Beth A Harney
770-518-****
Caitlin M Gaich Age: 27
Residential status:
Homeowner
Charles Bruce Hubley Age: 106
317-842-****
Julian W Blackwell Age: 65
317-251-****

Businesses

Organization Phone Number Additional Info
Draw It to Know It, LLC
317-446-****
Industry:
Nonclassifiable Establishments
Site:
drawittoknowit.com
Gregory Gaich MD
Industry:
Internist
Gregory A Gaich Age: 65
516-617-****
Residential status:
Homeowner
Job:
Medical Professional
Type:
Medical
MD (Doctor of Medicine)

Where is 5891 New Jersey St, Indianapolis IN located on map?

New Jersey St Fire Incident History

To date, we have no information about fire incidents in 2025
09 Dec 2017 Building fires
Property Use —
1 or 2 family dwelling
Area of Origin —
Substructure area or space, crawl space
First Ignition —
Soft goods, wearing apparel, other
Heat Source —
Spark, ember or flame from operating equipment
29 Nov 2017 Outside rubbish fire, other
Property Use —
1 or 2 family dwelling
Area of Origin —
Outside area, other
First Ignition —
Light vegetation - not crop, including grass
Heat Source —
Hot ember or ash
20 Oct 2017 Passenger vehicle fire
Property Use —
Residential street, road or residential driveway
Area of Origin —
Operator/passenger area of transportation equip.
First Ignition —
Flammable liquid/gas in container or pipe
Heat Source —
Multiple heat sources including multiple ignitions
14 Dec 2008 Building fires
Property Use —
1 or 2 family dwelling
Area of Origin —
Laundry area, wash house (laundry)
First Ignition —
Wearing apparel not on a person

View more

New Jersey St Incidents registered in FEMA
(Federal Emergency Management Agency)

To date, we have no information about incidents registered in FEMA in 2025
05 Apr 2013 Hazardous condition, other
Property Use —
1 or 2 family dwelling
13 Jan 2013 Power line down
Property Use —
1 or 2 family dwelling
29 Jun 2012 Power line down
Property Use —
1 or 2 family dwelling
18 Jun 2012 Outside rubbish fire, other
Property Use —
Street, other

View more

Properties Nearby

Street AddressResidens/Landlords
 

FAQ about the house at 5891 New Jersey St, Indianapolis, IN


NOTICE: You may not use RadioAwards or the information it provides to make decisions about employment, credit, housing or any other purpose that would require Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) compliance. RadioAwards is not a Consumer Reporting Agency (CRA) as defined by the FCRA and does not provide consumer reports.