5537 Gay St Toledo, OH 43613 / 1910

Map

Residence for Single Family

(UPDATED: 07/25/2025)
  • 2 Beds
  • 1 Baths
  • 6.500 square feet
Property Report

Information about property on 5537 Gay St, Toledo OH, 43613-1910. Find out owner contacts, building history, price, neighborhood at Homemetry Address Directory.

Property Details

At 5537 Gay Street, Toledo, OH there is a single-family residence.

Facts

  • Built in 1924
  • Lot size 6,500 sqft
  • Rooms 5
  • Bedrooms 2
  • Bathrooms 1
  • Stories 1 story with attic and basement
  • Basement Full Basement
  • Exterior Home Features
  • Exterior walls Siding (Alum/Vinyl)

Listing info

  • Last sold Aug 2003 for $71,800

Householders and Tenants for 5537 Gay St, Toledo OH

Possible residents contact details

Person Name Phone Number Additional Info
Charles J Wechsel
Michael D Brittingham
419-471-****
Residential status:
Homeowner
Email:
[email protected]
Michelle L Brittingham Age: 54
419-471-****
Residential status:
Homeowner
Job:
Craftsman/Blue Collar
Michelle L White
Vanessa M Matheson Age: 56

Purchase History

DateEventPriceSourceAgents
08/12/2003 Sold $71,800 Public records
09/25/1997 Sold $41,250 Public records

Cost estimate history

YearTaxAssessmentMarket
2013 $985 $14,460 N/A

Where is 5537 Gay St, Toledo OH located on map?

Gay St Fire Incident History

To date, we have no information about fire incidents in 2025
04 Dec 2006 Structure fire, other (conversion only)
5732 Gay St, Toledo OH
Property Use —
1 or 2 family dwelling
Area of Origin —
Bedroom - < 5 persons; included are jail or prison
First Ignition —
Electrical wire, cable insulation
Heat Source —
Arcing
18 Oct 2001 Structure fire, other (conversion only)
5730 Gay St, Toledo OH
Property Use —
Multifamily dwellings
Area of Origin —
Cooking area, kitchen
First Ignition —
Cooking materials, including edible materials
Heat Source —
Radiated, conducted heat from operating equipment
03 Jun 2000 Mobile property (vehicle) fire, other
5520 Gay St, Toledo OH
Property Use —
Residential street, road or residential driveway
Area of Origin —
Operator/passenger area of transportation equip.
First Ignition —
Upholstered sofa, chair, vehicle seats
12 Mar 1999 Structure fire, other (conversion only)
5720 Gay St, Toledo OH
Property Use —
Multifamily dwellings
Area of Origin —
Common room, den, family room, living room, lounge
First Ignition —
Upholstered sofa, chair, vehicle seats
Heat Source —
Cigarette

View more

Gay St Incidents registered in FEMA
(Federal Emergency Management Agency)

To date, we have no information about incidents registered in FEMA in 2025
12 Apr 2015 Authorized controlled burning
5548 Gay St, Toledo OH
Property Use —
Parking garage, (detached residential garage)
01 Jun 2014 Authorized controlled burning
5652 Gay St, Toledo OH
Property Use —
Graded and cared-for plots of land
20 Mar 2009 Electrical wiring/equipment problem, other
5730 Gay St, Toledo OH
Property Use —
Multifamily dwellings
23 Nov 2000 Natural vegetation fire, other
5900 Gay St, Toledo OH
Property Use —
Residential street, road or residential driveway

View more

Properties Nearby

Street AddressResidens/Landlords
5513 Gay St, Toledo, OH 43613-1910
Single Family Residential
  • 3 beds
  • 1 bath
  • Lot: 0.46 acres
  • Built in 1925
 Eric Vandergrift, Eric J Vandegrift
5520 Gay St, Toledo, OH 43613-1911
Single Family Residential
  • 2 beds
  • 1 bath
  • 778 sqft
  • Built in 1925
 Steven J Hybarger, Dale A Martin
5523 Gay St, Toledo, OH 43613-1910
Single Family Residential
  • 3 beds
  • 1 bath
  • Lot: 6,500 sqft
  • Built in 1956
 Jennifer Ann Kenyon, Jennifer A Landis
5532 Gay St, Toledo, OH 43613-1911
Single Family Residential
  • 3 beds
  • 1 bath
  • Lot: 0.29 acres
  • Built in 1925
 Daniel W Oberski, Kathleen M Oberski
5533 Gay St, Toledo, OH 43613-1910
Single Family Residential
  • 2 beds
  • 1 bath
  • Lot: 6,500 sqft
  • Built in 1949
 Linda L Ross, Pamela S Ross
5538 Gay St, Toledo, OH 43613-1911
Single Family Residential
  • 2 beds
  • 1 bath
  • Lot: 7,500 sqft
  • Built in 1941
 Watson D Allen, Diane J Depew
5547 Gay St, Toledo, OH 43613-1910
Single Family Residential
  • 3 beds
  • 1 bath
  • 858 sqft
  • Built in 1925
 Hubert Bondy, Diane M Hoffsis
5548 Gay St, Toledo, OH 43613-1911
Single Family Residential
  • 3 beds
  • 1 bath
  • Lot: 5,100 sqft
  • Built in 1973
 Handley H Keener, Julius G Lowe
5550 Gay St, Toledo, OH 43613-1911
Single Family Residential
  • 3 beds
  • 1 bath
  • 1,368 sqft
  • Built in 1926
 Lisa A Beins, Ka A Lauwers
5555 Gay St, Toledo, OH 43613-1910
Single Family Residential
  • 4 beds
  • 2 baths
  • Lot: 4,700 sqft
  • Built in 1942
 Donald L Smay, Joyce M Smay

Gay Street

Recently Sold Homes on Gay Street (3)

Recent rentals on Gay Street (1)

Toledo, OH

Houses for Sale on Toledo, OH (88)

Recently Sold Homes on Toledo, OH (4997)

Houses for Rent on Toledo, OH (19)

Recent rentals on Toledo, OH (1397)

 

FAQ about the house at 5537 Gay St, Toledo, OH


NOTICE: You may not use RadioAwards or the information it provides to make decisions about employment, credit, housing or any other purpose that would require Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) compliance. RadioAwards is not a Consumer Reporting Agency (CRA) as defined by the FCRA and does not provide consumer reports.